Coding, computing, and computational thinking are terms that currently dominate the debate on digital skills development in Europe and worldwide. This is influenced by the rising demand of ICT specialists in the labour market and countries looking for ways to provide the demanded skills for the young generation. Computing is also valued as a subject that contributes to the intellectual and personal development of young people: it stimulates creativity, critical and logical thinking, problem solving, and facilitates understanding of how digital technologies function1. In other words, computing transforms students from consumers to creators of the digital world.
In October 2015, ICDL Foundation published a position paper titled, ‘Computing and Digital Literacy: Call for a Holistic Approach’2. In the paper, we discussed the key terminology around computing and digital literacy, and we overviewed different approaches around the development of computing skills. We also suggested a balanced approach in digital skills development, which includes key elements of digital literacy and computing.
One of the key arguments of our paper published in 2015 was that coding/programming is only one element of computing. Hence, when computing is introduced to children in school, teaching should begin with the basics of computational thinking and problem solving, followed by the practical implementation, such as coding. We also stated that every student should have an opportunity to learn the fundamentals of computing at school in order to be able to specialise in this discipline at later stages of education. Finally, after overviewing a variety of approaches of teaching computing, we identified a need for a standardised approach. This comprehensive approach should encompass both computing and digital literacy as two substantial elements of digital competence.
In February 2017, ICDL Foundation launched the new Computing module. This module, aimed at secondary school students, sets out essential concepts and skills relating to the use of computational thinking and coding. It will be relevant, not only for students who are interested in computing, but also for those who wish to develop transversal skills such as problem solving skills. This module can certify skills acquired either during extra-curricular activities or as part of the more formal curriculum.
In this new paper, we update the standpoint of ICDL Foundation in public debate around computing and digital literacy and position the ICDL programme against existing structures such as the DigComp framework. Firstly, this paper overviews terms and concepts related to computing. Secondly, it argues that computing is part of digital competence. Thirdly, it discusses different approaches to computing skills development in different countries. Finally, the paper presents the key elements of the new ICDL Computing module and explains how it answers the need for a consistent, high-quality approach in building and certifying computing skills.
The term ‘computing’
ICDL Foundation uses the term ‘computing’ interchangeably with ‘computer science’ – an academic discipline covering principles such as algorithms, data structures, programming, systems architecture, problem solving, etc. Computer science encompasses foundational principles (such as the theory of computation) and widely applicable ideas and concepts (such as the use of relational models to capture structure in data)3.
At the end of 2016, the Joint Research Center (JRC) of the European Commission published a CompuThink study4, which aimed at clarifying the term ‘computational thinking’ (CT). The researchers overviewed more than 570 sources from academic and grey literature, surveyed 19 ministries of education in Europe, and carried out 14 interviews with experts on the topic. After analysing this data, researchers concluded that there is a lack of consensus on the term of ‘computational thinking’ and that countries in Europe use different terms to describe the same subject:
- Computational thinking
- Computer science
- Algorithmic thinking
- Coding, etc.
When different terms are used to describe the same concept, the best approach is to name the key components of this concept in order to define it. JRC chose this strategy to define computational thinking: they outlined the key concepts and skills that repeatedly fall under this term throughout different sources5:
- Algorithmic thinking
In other words, no matter which term is used in different countries (computer science, computing, or computational thinking), they all refer to the same concept as long as they retain the key elements mentioned above. In order to retain consistency with ICDL Foundation’s paper published in 20156, we continue to use the term ‘computing’.
The CompuThink study confirms ICDL Foundation’s argument that computing is much more than simply programming/coding7. Computing is a key to problem analysis and problem decomposition, whereas coding/programming helps to implement given solutions in a particular programming language and can serve as a learning tool8. ICDL Foundation strongly believes that all key concepts of computing should be taught together in order to equip students with a full set of transferrable skills and knowledge. The new ICDL Computing module covers all essential concepts and skills relating to computing (see module description in Chapter 5).
Computing as part of digital competence
ICDL Foundation believes that computing and digital literacy are two sides of the same coin and both of them should form part of compulsory education. Digital skills should be developed progressively in education, starting with the essential skills required to use a computer and get online, and then continuing with more complex skills such as computing, IT security, and web editing. Figure 1 represents an example of how to balance digital literacy skills and computing in school curricula.
ICDL Foundation believes that computing skills and digital literacy skills are essential elements of digital competence. As defined by JRC, digital competence is a “confident, critical and creative use of ICT to achieve goals related to work, employability, learning, leisure, inclusion and/or participation in society”9. The key elements of digital competence are outlined by the DigComp Framework for citizens (DigComp)10, which was developed by the JRC in order to facilitate the development and understanding of digital competences in Europe. This Framework outlines five digital competence areas: information and data literacy, communication and collaboration, digital content creation, safety and problem solving.
The ICDL programme covers all digital competence areas outlined by DigComp11. The ICDL Computing module, in particular, covers competences under the DigComp competence areas, ‘Digital content creation’ and ‘Problem solving’.
DigComp and ICDL
Find out more about how the ICDL Computing module relates to the EU’s DigComp framework.
Computing skills development in Europe and worldwide
For several years, computing has been high on the political agenda both in Europe and worldwide. The European Commission calls coding the literacy of today, which is fundamental in understanding how digital technologies work and serves in developing 21st century skills such as problem solving and analytical thinking12. Moreover, the European Commission considers teaching computing as a promising solution to satisfy the rising demand for ICT professionals in Europe. The New Skills Agenda for Europe invites Member States to invest more into digital skills development, including coding and computer science13.
European countries are increasingly implementing computing into their school curricula. The CompuThink report14 reveals that eleven countries have recently included computing in their compulsory education: Denmark, France, Finland, Croatia, Italy, Malta, Poland, Turkey, England and Scotland. Seven countries specified that they have plans to introduce computing into their school curriculum: the Czech Republic, Greece, Ireland, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden and Wales. Finally, seven countries have already had computing as part of their school curriculum (mainly upper secondary level) for a number of years: Austria, Portugal, Cyprus, Israel, Lithuania, Hungary and Slovakia. Some of these countries are planning to include computing in lower secondary and primary schools.
There is a trend of introducing computing into compulsory education all around the globe. The CompuThink study provides examples from Australia, British Columbia (Canada), Japan, New Zealand, Singapore and South Korea15. In Australia, since 2015, digital technologies are addressed as a whole discipline with the curriculum focussed mainly on algorithms and problem solving. In Singapore, the new subject of ‘Computing’ will start in 2017 at the Secondary 3 level. In British Columbia, Canada, from the school-year 2016-17, computing is integrated from grades 6 to 8 as part of the subject, ‘Applied Design, Skills and Technologies’16. In early 2016, the former President of the USA, Barack Obama, launched the ‘Computer Science for All’ initiative aiming to provide an opportunity for all American students to learn computer science17. The key rationale for all of these countries to introduce computing into school curriculum is to foster 21st century skills such as logical thinking and problem solving18.
All of these examples from Europe and worldwide show that many countries are willing to integrate computing into their compulsory education. In addition to these efforts, multiple extra-curricular activities such as volunteer-led Code Clubs19 and Coder Dojos20 are mushrooming worldwide. They are supported by international campaigns such as the Hour of Code21, Code Week22 and the Africa Code Week23.
In this large variety of different approaches and teaching practices for computing skills, ICDL Foundation suggests a well thought-out and thoroughly developed approach to computing skills development – the ICDL Computing Module.
ICDL Computing module
The new ICDL Computing module, which was developed with input from experts in the field, sets out the essential concepts and skills relating to the use of computational thinking and coding to create simple computer programs. This module introduces concepts and skills that are essential for anyone interested in developing specialised IT skills and it also assists in developing generic problem solving skills that are useful for everyone. The outline of the Computing module is provided in Table 1.
|Computational thinking methods||
|Starting to code||
|Building using code||
|Test, debug, and release||
Table 1: Syllabus outline of ICDL Computing module
Different approaches to computing skills development
For countries that are on the way to introducing coding as part of their education systems, it is important to answer several key questions: first, should computing be taught as part of the school curriculum or as an extra-curricular activity; second, at which education level should it be integrated (primary or secondary); and third, how to support teachers who will be teaching computing.
Computing as part of the school curriculum or an extra-curricular activity?
Curriculum overload is a relevant issue in many countries. Education systems are pressured to integrate numerous subjects in already tight schedules and teachers have to rapidly adapt to the changing needs. In this context, offering a new subject as an after-school activity seems like an attractive idea, especially since numerous volunteer-based activities already take place in different countries. However, only by integrating computing into compulsory education, can we make sure that it is taught in a structured, comprehensive and inclusive way.
First, the interest in participating in coding clubs substantially exceeds the supply24. It means that only the most motivated children (or children with motivated parents) can participate in these activities.
Second, there are some stereotypes that exist about computing (it is for boys, ‘geeks’, etc.)25. As a consequence, many children who could potentially get interested in this subject, lack an incentive to try it.
Third, some after-school activities are organised with the principle of ‘bring your own device’. Children from disadvantaged backgrounds who do not posses digital devices, might be excluded from coding activities.
In comparison, when computing is part of the school curriculum, all children have access to this subject. BCS stresses that computing is a rigorous and demanding subject, thus all means should be taken to ensure that young people from disadvantaged backgrounds have no barriers to achieve the highest results26.
Finally, most of the after-school activities teach children the basics of coding, but not the other essential elements of computing (such as problem analysis, algorithms, etc.). In order to ensure that every child learns the fundamentals of computing starting with problem analysis and problem decomposition and finishing with practical implementation such as coding, computing should be introduced in compulsory school curricula. The fact of introducing a subject into the school curriculum ensures that it is taught in a systematic and structured manner.
Children who have already acquired computing skills through extra-curricular activities, should have an opportunity to certify these skills based on a recognised standard. In this case, the ICDL Computing module could serve as a practical solution.
Which education level?
Most European countries have integrated computing at secondary education27. There is also a growing trend to introduce this subject from primary school (for example, in Finland, England (UK) and France). This trend is driven by the idea that, in order for students to better grasp the concepts of computing, they should be integrated into the early years of education. However, the CompuThink study states that, at the moment, there is not enough evidence to clearly define the optimal age to start learning computing28. Some authors call for more research about what is the earliest stage from which students can understand and work with abstraction29.
The new ICDL Computing Module was developed for secondary and vocational school students around 12-16 years old who wish to start learning about computational thinking and coding. This age group is typically ready to engage in relatively complex concepts relating to problem solving and is also ready to use flexible, easily readable programming languages such as Python. The module is likely to be of interest not only to students who are interested in IT and computing, but also to those who wish to develop transversal skills relating to problem solving.
How to support teachers?
In order to ensure high-quality computing education, it is necessary to provide substantial support for teachers. According to BCS, the most challenging task for teachers is to develop the required subject knowledge in parallel to pedagogical practice in order to teach computing in an engaging way30. Support for teachers should involve both technical skills and pedagogical aspects, as well as useful tips on how to make computing classes engaging and attractive.
With the launch of the new Computing Module, ICDL Foundation has prepared supporting materials for teachers who will teach computing. These materials give additional information, exercises, and references relating to the specific content set out in the students’ learning materials, and act as an important additional resource to support module delivery.
Computing, computational thinking and computer science are terms that are often used to define the same concept, which encompasses the following elements: abstraction, algorithmic thinking, automation, decomposition, debugging and generalisation. ICDL Foundation uses the term computing to maintain consistency with our previous position paper, “Computing and Digital Literacy: Call for a Holistic Approach”.
ICDL Foundation believes that computing skills and digital literacy skills are essential elements of digital competence and should form part of compulsory education. The ICDL programme covers all digital competence areas outlined by DigComp, the digital competence framework for citizens.
Computing is being integrated into compulsory education in a number of countries in Europe and worldwide. These activities are complemented by volunteer-led after-school activities such as Code Clubs. In this large variety of different approaches and teaching practices, ICDL Foundation provides a high-quality solution to computing skills development.
The recently launched ICDL Computing module was developed to rigorously high standards with the input of subject matter experts and practicing computing professionals from around the world, ensuring that it is both relevant and comprehensive. This module is likely to be of interest, not only to students who are inclined towards computing, but also to those who wish to develop their transversal skills, such as problem solving.
The ICDL Computing module could be used as a basis for computing skills development in compulsory education as well as a solution to certify skills acquired through extra-curricular activities. The key target audience of this module is secondary school students, around 12-16 years old, because they are ready to engage with the relatively complex concepts related to problem solving. The module is complemented with additional materials, which were developed specifically to support teachers in teaching computing.
The ICDL Computing module was developed to help empower young people to build key skills for the future.
References and footnotes
1: BCS Academy of Computing, “Excellent Computing in Every School: a Toolkit for School Leaders”, https://www.computingatschool.org.uk/custom_pages/200-schoolleaders
2: ECDL Foundation “Computing and Digital Literacy. Call for a Holistic Approach”, 2015, http://ecdl.org/media/position_paper_-_computing_and_ digital_literacy.pdf
4: Joint Research Center, “Developing Computational Thinking in Compulsory Education”, 2016, https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/publication/eur-scientific-and-technical-research-reports/developing-computational-thinking-compulsory-education-implications-policy-and-practice
6: ECDL Foundation “Computing and Digital Literacy. Call for a Holistic Approach”, 2015, http://ecdl.org/media/position_paper_-_computing_and_ digital_literacy.pdf
8: Joint Research Center, “Developing Computational Thinking in Compulsory Education”, 2016, https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/publication/eur-scientific-and-technical-research-reports/developing-computational-thinking-compulsory-education-implications-policy-and-practice
9: JRC “Digital Competence in Practice: An Analysis of Frameworks”, 2012, https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/news/digital-competence-practice-analysis-frameworks
10: JRC, DigComp, https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/digcomp/digital-competence-framework
11: JRC, DigComp Gallery of Implementations, https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/digcomp/implementation
12: European Commission “Coding – the 21st Century Skill”, https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/coding-21st-century-skill
13: European Commission “A New Skills Agenda for Europe. Working together to strengthen human capital, employability and competitiveness”, 10.06.2016, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A52016DC0381
14: Joint Research Center, “Developing Computational Thinking in Compulsory Education”, 2016, https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/publication/eur-scientific-and-technical-research-reports/developing-computational-thinking-compulsory-education-implications-policy-and-practice
17: Megan Smith “Computer Science for All”, https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/blog/2016/01/30/computer-science-all; “Fact Sheet: a Year of Action Supporting Computer Science for All”, https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2016/12/05/fact-sheet-year-action-supporting-computer-science-all; https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/blog/2016/10/27/call-new-csforall-actions-during-computer-science-education-week
18: Joint Research Center, “Developing Computational Thinking in Compulsory Education”, 2016, https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/publication/eur-scientific-and-technical-research-reports/developing-computational-thinking-compulsory-education-implications-policy-and-practice
25: Allison Master, “Researchers explain how stereotypes keep girls out of computer science classes”, https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/education/wp/2016/04/26/researchers-explain-how-stereotypes-keep-girls-out-of-computer-science-classes/
26: BCS Academy of Computing, “Excellent Computing in Every School: a Toolkit for School Leaders”, https://www.computingatschool.org.uk/custom_pages/200-schoolleaders
27: Joint Research Center, “Developing Computational Thinking in Compulsory Education”, 2016, https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/publication/eur-scientific-and-technical-research-reports/developing-computational-thinking-compulsory-education-implications-policy-and-practice
30: BCS Academy of Computing “Teaching, Learning and Assessment”, https://web.archive.org/web/20170629144546/http://www.computingatschool.org.uk/custom_pages/204-assessment